New Mexico’s doctor shortage stems from long-term policies and training limits.
New Mexico’s long struggle to maintain enough doctors has grown more visible in recent years, but the roots of the issue run far deeper than many realize. For decades, residents across the state have lived with long drives, long wait times, and the constant worry of not being able to see a doctor when health concerns arise. Some voices have pointed toward legal battles involving medical mistakes as the main reason for the New Mexico doctor shortage, but that claim overlooks the many forces that have shaped the current landscape. The situation involves long-standing policy choices, federal limits on training new doctors, and financial rules that shaped how insurance works for both hospitals and medical offices.
Decades ago, the state created a special fund to help those harmed by medical mistakes while also shielding doctors from being overwhelmed by claims. When the fund was formed in the mid-1970s, the allowed financial recovery for injured patients was set at a level that would be far higher today when adjusted for inflation. Over the years, only small increases were made, and recent adjustments still sit far below what the original amount would equal now. These changes were never large enough to set off the concern raised by some groups. What did matter was how the fund was used and who was allowed to join it. For several years, large hospitals were admitted even though the fund had never been designed to cover them. Their addition caused a rise in claims and placed the fund under heavy pressure. Correcting this mistake required new rules and new payments from both doctors and hospitals.
The state agency that oversees the system also placed rules on what kind of insurance policy doctors must buy. These rules required a more expensive type of policy, even though a more affordable option exists and is widely used elsewhere. Because of this, doctors ended up facing higher insurance prices not due to lawsuits, but due to rules that prevented them from choosing a cheaper plan. Hospitals that employ doctors often cover these costs, but smaller clinics and independent doctors feel the impact more directly, contributing to the New Mexico doctor shortage.
Across the nation, a deeper issue has played an even larger part in limiting the number of new doctors. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, national leaders believed the country would soon have too many doctors. As a result, the federal government slowed the growth of medical schools and later locked funding for residency training at levels set nearly thirty years ago. Because of these restrictions, thousands of medical school graduates every year cannot enter residency programs, which keeps them from becoming practicing physicians. No lawsuit, insurance policy, or state rule can solve a shortage created by these long-standing national limits.
When doctors choose where to work, research shows that their main concerns include quality of life and being close to loved ones. The legal environment around medical mistakes ranks far lower. This means changes that only adjust lawsuit rules do little to attract new doctors. More helpful steps include creating more residency openings within the state, offering better pay during training, covering housing costs, and helping doctors with heavy student loan debt if they commit to staying. Keeping medical practices in the hands of trained professionals, rather than outside investors, may also create a more stable environment for both doctors and patients. Adjusting insurance rules so doctors can pick more affordable policy types would remove unnecessary costs, and strong investment strategies for the state fund could further reduce financial pressure. Doctors with clean records could also receive breaks on their premiums, while those with repeated problems could receive extra training or support.
The New Mexico doctor shortage did not happen overnight, and it cannot be fixed with simple claims or blame. The situation involves long-term national decisions, state rules that raised costs without clear benefits, and deep gaps in training opportunities. Real solutions call for practical changes that help doctors start their careers in the state and stay there. With clear information and thoughtful action, progress is possible.
Sources:
OPINION: Solutions for New Mexico’s doctor shortage
Why New Mexico Can’t Keep Its Doctors — And What We Can Do About It
Join the conversation!