Private equity acquisitions worsen hospital care quality, patient satisfaction, and equity over time.
A recent study by researchers at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center has revealed that patient care tends to decline after hospitals are acquired by private equity firms. The findings, published in JAMA, show that as time passes, care quality and patient satisfaction worsen compared to hospitals that remain independent. The analysis included data from 73 hospitals acquired by private equity firms between 2008 and 2019, compared to 293 hospitals that did not undergo such acquisitions.
The study focused on several key areas of patient-reported experiences, such as staff responsiveness, communication with doctors and nurses, and overall hospital environment. Patients who had firsthand interactions with the care system provided valuable insights, highlighting a concerning trend: their experiences with care noticeably worsened in the years following private equity takeovers. This decline in patient satisfaction was especially pronounced in how promptly and effectively hospital staff responded to patients’ needs.
The researchers attribute these declines to profit-driven strategies often employed by private equity firms. These firms typically focus on short-term financial returns, which may lead to cost-cutting measures that negatively impact patient care. Reduced staffing levels, less emphasis on maintaining hospital infrastructure, and changes in care delivery practices are some potential reasons for the observed decline in patient experiences.
One of the researchers, Dr. Rishi Wadhera, emphasized the importance of patient feedback, noting that it offers a comprehensive view of the care experience. He pointed out that the downward trend in patient satisfaction is troubling, especially given the
growing number of hospitals being purchased by private equity investors. Over the past decade, private equity firms have poured hundreds of billions of dollars into healthcare acquisitions, reshaping the landscape of patient care.
The financial incentives behind these acquisitions often prioritize efficiency and profitability over patient well-being. Short-term investment strategies may include trimming budgets, restructuring services, or prioritizing high-margin procedures, all of which can disrupt the continuity and quality of care. This approach might yield immediate financial gains but at the cost of deteriorating care quality.
In addition to worsening patient experiences, the study notes broader implications for healthcare equity. Previous research by Dr. Wadhera revealed that private equity firms tend to acquire practices and hospitals located in wealthier areas, potentially diverting resources away from underserved communities. This pattern raises concerns about access to quality care for patients in less affluent regions, further deepening disparities in healthcare outcomes.
The research team also explored the potential consequences of private equity ownership on specific aspects of care. For instance, patients reported poorer communication with healthcare providers and a noticeable decline in the overall hospital environment. These changes are particularly significant because they can directly affect recovery times, adherence to medical advice, and overall patient outcomes.
The study’s findings underscore the need for greater transparency and regulatory oversight in the growing presence of private equity in healthcare. Dr. Wadhera and his team advocate for policies that safeguard patient care standards and ensure that financial motivations do not compromise the quality of services provided.
While private equity investments can bring capital and resources to healthcare facilities, the researchers caution that such investments should be balanced with a commitment to maintaining high standards of care. Without adequate monitoring and regulation, the pursuit of profit risks overshadowing the core mission of healthcare: to provide compassionate and effective care to all patients.
The findings are a call to action for policymakers, healthcare leaders, and communities to critically evaluate the long-term impact of private equity’s influence on the healthcare system. Ensuring that patients remain the priority in any healthcare setting is essential for preserving trust, promoting recovery, and achieving better health outcomes. By addressing these challenges, stakeholders can work toward a healthcare system that is both financially sustainable and focused on delivering quality care.
Sources:
Patient care declines after private equity buys hospitals, study finds
Changes in Patient Care Experience After Private Equity Acquisition of US Hospitals
Join the conversation!