Researchers find that smokers who switched from cigarettes to e-cigarettes saw notable improvements in respiratory symptoms.
Switching from smoking to vaping has been found to offer improvements in respiratory health, according to a new study published in Nicotine and Tobacco Research. The team specifically examined whether long-held claims that switching from traditional to e-cigarettes—commonly marketed as a safer alternative due to fewer harmful chemicals—is better for one’s health and whether these claims would hold up over time.
To explore this notion, researchers analyzed data from the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) study, a large-scale, national survey of tobacco use conducted by the National Institutes of Health (NIH). Their analysis included adult participants who were exclusively cigarette smokers at the time of the current study’s onset and reported common respiratory symptoms like coughing and wheezing. By observing these smokers over several years, the team sought to determine how different nicotine use behaviors impacted respiratory symptoms.
The subjects were split into four groups: those who quit nicotine entirely, those who switched exclusively to vaping, those who continued to smoke cigarettes only, and those who took up both smoking and vaping simultaneously. Results showed that the participants who transitioned entirely to e-cigarettes experienced a significant reduction in wheezing symptoms, a commonly reported side effect of smoking.
In contrast, participants who continued to smoke, even with added vaping, did not see an improvement in respiratory health and, in some cases, experienced worsening symptoms. The data also highlighted that reducing smoking intensity while adding e-cigarettes did not produce respiratory benefits. At the same time, individuals who quit nicotine altogether demonstrated the greatest improvement in respiratory symptoms, suggesting that the complete cessation of nicotine intake, in all forms of smoking, may be the most beneficial strategy for resolving respiratory issues.
Specifically, among the 5,210 participants with a baseline cough, 65% saw improvements, and among the 5,367 individuals with wheezing, 53% reported relief. However, dual-use participants who maintained or increased their smoking habits did not see similar benefits. In fact, dual users who continued smoking at the same levels experienced a 14% and 15% lower rate of cough and wheeze resolution, respectively, compared to those who switched exclusively to vaping.
These findings suggest that, while switching to e-cigarettes can lead to certain respiratory improvements, the benefits are more noticeable in those who entirely replace smoking with vaping. Also, maintaining both habits negates the potential respiratory advantages, which could indicate that dual use reinforces harmful smoking patterns rather than reducing exposure to toxic substances.
Lung cancer remains one of the most common cancers in the United States, accounting for approximately one in four cancer deaths. Rates have gradually declined in recent years due to a reduction in cigarette smoking, improved awareness, and new preventive measures. However, lung cancer still has one of the highest mortality rates among all forms of the disease, partly because it is often detected in later stages when symptoms become more obvious. Smoking is the primary risk factor, but other factors like radon exposure, air pollution, and genetic predispositions also contribute. Disparities exist across demographics, with higher rates often observed in low-income and certain racial and ethnic populations, underscoring the need for targeted prevention and early detection efforts.
This study provides an essential perspective on harm reduction in tobacco use, emphasizing the benefits of transitioning from cigarettes to e-cigarettes rather than adding vaping to an existing smoking habit. However, quitting nicotine completely remains the most effective approach for improving respiratory health.
Sources:
Switching from smoking to vaping improves respiratory health
Association of Cigarette–E-Cigarette Transitions With Respiratory Symptom Resolution
Join the conversation!